Author Archives: Nicole

Liz Lemoning?

Never heard of Liz Lemoning? Me either til I read Why High-Achieving Women Pretend Their Lives Are A Mess

Did you ever watch “I Don’t Know How She Does It?” from 2011 starring Sarah Jessica Parker? I did. I wanted to like it. I didn’t like it.

My movie review: https://workingmom.guru/2015/07/i-dont-know-how-she-does-it-movie-review/

When I read this article recently, it helped to identify some of my frustration.

In short: Liz Lemon was a Hot Mess. Her Hot Mess Syndrome — the affliction of so many successful women everywhere — was precisely the point. Whether or not you think she’s a revolutionary figure, the Hot Mess has a lot to tell us about our contradictory expectations of high-achieving women under late-capitalist patriarchy.

Why do successful women insist on pretending they aren’t? Maybe because we’re trying to apologize for being successful?

On account of her smarts and circumstances, the Hot Mess gets that her success needs to look a little bit like an accident in order not to garner resentment. Her messiness is equal parts internalized misogyny and compensatory measure.

Do we even know we are doing it?

Fey’s not really a mess. But it’s telling that her fictional analogue is. We can learn a lot about ourselves by what we find funny and what we decide to show others.

Pandemic is unraveling feminists’ hard work

So hard to see the multiple headlines echoing the impact that the COVID-19 pandemic is having on women.

Some recent headlines highlighting the issues:

This pandemic threatens to undo what generations of feminists have fought for

Pandemic Makes Evident ‘Grotesque’ Gender Inequality In Household Work

The coronavirus pandemic is creating a ‘double double shift’ for women. Employers must help

A few snippets from these articles that resonate.

“The old model of our education system where everyone sits in a classroom is not going to work in the new normal,” Cuomo argued. What he did not mention is that remote schooling still requires children to be supervised. The result is that parents – overwhelmingly, mothers – will effectively be deputized as teachers, without training or pay, and required to stay home with their kids. Cuomo’s decision is premised on the sexist assumption that women are perpetually available for more and more unpaid domestic work. In fact, it elevates that attitude from a cultural and marital injustice to a pillar of public policy.

I realize no parent signed up for this. Sure, some have always home schooled, and kudos to them! The rest of us were wholly unprepared to teach our kids.

The state is retreating from its obligation to provide an education for children, and the childcare that that education represents. Women are inevitably tasked with compensating for the state’s failures. With the state rolling back services, private companies making few concessions to women workers’ domestic needs, and men not picking up the slack, the post-pandemic world could mean smaller, more claustrophobic and more constrained lives for women.

I don’t know that women are inevitably tasked, but certainly women are inequitably tasked with compensating for the absence of state provided education. And it absolutely disproportionately impacts women’s lives.

On why she advises against picking up the slack on housework that a partner does sloppily Through the years, we would have these agreements — you do this and I do this — and then typically [my husband] would always just slack off and wouldn’t do it, and then I would always pick it up. And then that would just increase my sense of anger, because it would feel so unfair. And that’s actually a phenomenon. It’s called “learned helplessness.” …

Valuable insight.

On how women often assume the responsibility for “invisible work,” such as maintaining schedules and maintaining family ties There’s a whole body of research around what’s called “the mental load.” It’s something that women also disproportionately bear. … It’s all of the stuff that you have to keep in your mind. It’s just an explosion of details and logistics and planning and organizing and making appointments and remembering the appointments and getting people to the appointments, remembering birthdays, doing the “kinwork” … keeping the ties, the family and bonds of friends, keeping those strong. …

I personally like to make a list, and show off what I have done. Quantifies it and ensures I talk about it so it doesn’t go unrecognized.

This is the time for managers to become leaders by giving their teams much-needed emotional support. Fewer than a third of employees—and fewer than a quarter of essential workers—say someone from their company checks in on their well-being these days. If employees are homeschooling kids or worrying about a parent in the hospital, their managers should know that and adjust work plans accordingly.

This is great advice. If you are in a leadership position, please do this. Support your teams, both by checking in, and by adjusting expectations.

We need to come out of this pandemic stronger, and the best way to do this, don’t give up progress, yes, nurture and love your families, but expect that everyone in your family will also nurture and love you.

When will we have equal rights under the law?

I’ve been watching the FX show Mrs. America on Hulu. It is a Docudrama about the movement to ratify the Equal Rights Amendment (ERA). In January, I marched in the Women’s March here in Salt Lake City (much less participation than in my former home of Seattle), and many, myself included were wearing ERA buttons.

Maybe you don’t know this history – if not, lots of websites and books out there to familiarize yourself, or you could watch this docudrama. My abbreviated history. The ERA is a constitutional amendment. Do you know constitutional law? How about how many amendments have been made to the constitution? Ok, go read about that too.

Anyway, the ERA was introduced in 1923. That’s not a typo. Almost 100 years ago, women were fighting for equality. Wait, I thought women got the right to vote in 1928, you say? Then you really DO need to go read about the ERA. It is about equality! Not just women’s equality, but HUMAN equality.

The ERA passed the House and Senate in 1972, and then needed to be ratified by 38 states. That goal was also achieved just 48 years later in 2020 when Virginia became the 38th state to ratify. However the deadline for ratification had lapsed. The House then approved a resolution to remove the deadline, and it is waiting for Senate agreement.

I recall watching West Wing years ago, and hearing Republican Ainsley Hayes rail against the ERA. Her key point being she IS equal. I agree with this key premise. Where the argument falls apart is in understanding that is NOT what the ERA is about. It is to defend that equality in practice. To enforce for those that might not agree to at least act as if.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PQIkLTLf_IQ

So many women fought for and spent their lives pursuing this equality. So many years passed. Mrs. America taught me more about why we still do not have an equal right under the law.

Was it old white men getting in the way? Kind of. But the truly insidious were the WOMEN who fought AGAINST their own equality. Why? No, seriously, why?

Said no working mom EVER.

What time is it? Let’s see I get up at 4:30 to shower so that I can enjoy 30-60 minutes of “me” time, which often means falling back asleep, or working out, or reading, or checking email, …you get the picture.

Then its time to get the kids ready and deliver them safely and well fed to school (with maybe enough time to grab a coffee before the first meeting of the day).

Then you see the email from the school, asking for volunteers to help with some classroom event, at 10:15am. What?

Said no working mom EVER

I love getting emails about playgroups and fun, free activities that happen Tuesday at 10:15am… Said no working mom EVER.

“I love getting emails about playgrounds and fun, free activities that happen Tuesday at 10:15am… Said no working mom EVER.”

While I appreciate that some parents have the flexibility in their work lives, and SAHM/SAHDs can often drop things to help out, most working parents, and especially mom with a heightened awareness of taking time away from the office for her kids simply feel left out.

My volunteering at school has been consistently the same – I volunteer to chaperon field trips. I get to hang with my kid, do/see something fun, meet their classmates, meet a few parents, and it is all accomplished in a SINGLE DAY!

I get it, school schedules are tough, most are 6 hours in the middle of a workday. All I’m asking for is a little early heads up. With a little planning, my work has always offered the flexibility to take time, even midday. Is it convenient – never. But it can be done.

All parents want the opportunity to support their child’s education. Some do it with homework help, some volunteer in the classroom, some volunteer to do projects at home, or make things for Teacher Appreciation Week. We just ask for equal opportunity and recognition for the effort we are making on top of our full-time jobs.

Who is teaching the male executives?

I read the article What’s Your Kids’ Wage Gap? Boys Paid More, More Profitably the other day. I have 3 sons. My husband does much of our housework. My sons are learning to do all form of chores, and are not paid an allowance.

wage-gap
None of the information about girls and boys doing chores, being paid (more or less), working inside/outside the home, etc. bothered me as I know my husband and I are teaching our boys the right things. What got me? Well, how about this:

Pew found that 37% of men want stay-at-home wives, compared to 11% of women who wanted to be stay-at-home wives.

 37% of men want stay-at-home wives? Ok, I could still see my way to a blissful statement like “to each his own”, until I then read:

One of the systemic issues we face is that men (overwhelmingly the case, see below) who hold these attitudes are seriously over-represented in the very places where we need change the most — legislatures and the corporate world. For example, research conducted by the Families and Work Institute revealed that 75 percent of 1,200 male executives men surveyed had stay-at-home wives.

75% of male executives have stay-at-home wives? Out of curiosity, how many of the remaining 25% share equally the household and child care with their spouses?

But wait, it gets worse…

Employed husbands in traditional marriages, compared to those in modern marriages, tend to (a) view the presence of women in the workplace unfavorably, (b) perceive that organizations with higher numbers of female employees are operating less smoothly, (c) find organizations with female leaders as relatively unattractive, and (d) deny, more frequently, qualified female employees opportunities for promotion.

So I started reading an article about helping our young sons become better men, learning their value is neither greater nor less than a woman.

But that is not a message they will hear reinforced. Not when 75% of men have stay-at-home wives, and 37% want them.

My husband and I can address what chores my sons do. We can and do talk to them about what others perceive as gender-appropriate chores.

But who, among the 85% of Fortune 1000 companies with all-male boards will do the same for our corporate leaders? Who is teaching the male executives to change this same wage gap in the workplace?

Husband = Slacker or Partner?

A while ago, my husband sent me a link to a fascinating article (take a moment to read it, I’ll wait): Maximize Earning Potential by Marrying a Slacker

I had mixed reactions when I read it too.

  1. I know my husband’s contributions to our family and household are made possible by a less demanding job than my own at the moment – consistent with the outcome of the study.
  2. I know there have been times in our marriage where roles were reversed.
  3. I know that my husband works extremely hard at his job.
  4. I know household work and child care are no less of a job, and frankly the latter is often more of a job than any corporate job I’ve ever had.

But after reading this, the thing it reinforced for me most, the thing I KNOW is…

My husband is NO SLACKER!

We are partners. Always have been, always will be. We are connected. We sense when one of us needs some slack. We dive in when the other needs support.

Why is it that we still feel the need to make one person in a marriage out to be less than?

Are we still critical of working moms?

Watching The Intern with Anne Hathaway recently, I was delighted to see a character that I could relate to. She’s a perfectionist, driven by her own passion for her work and family. While I found the need to create conflict between her and her husband unfortunate, if you overlook this, I think I’ve finally watched a working mom movie I can endorse.

The character, she was real. When she committed to something at work, it got done, and done with high quality. When she committed to her family, she was there for them.

In one scene, she is dropping her young daughter off at school and is greeted by two moms. They ask her about bringing guacamole to a party at school a following Friday, and chide her by telling her she could buy it since she’s so busy. She retorts there is no need, she’ll make it. When she re-enters her car, she says, “God, taking the high road is exhausting. It’s 2015, are we really still critical of working moms? Seriously? Still?”

Amen. And yes, unfortunately, we are, but hopefully if we can keep portraying the reality of working moms, we love our jobs and our kids, maybe we can change that.

Thank you, Anne Hathaway, for a great movie. Made my Friday night!

Are there other good working mom movies I should watch?

Traditions – birthdays together

I decided the day my first son was born that I would spend each of his birthdays with him. Then a couple years later, his brother was born, and a couple years later, the third of my amazing sons joined our family. And each year, I mark their 3 birthdays on my work calendar as Out-Of-Office. This year will mark the 12th year of this tradition, spending their birthdays with them, and I would not trade it for the world. We don’t have to do anything big. Mostly we drop the brothers off at school, then we have a morning activity typically, the Children’s Museum, Aquarium, etc., a lunch out at one of their favorite restaurants, and just spend time together. It won’t be long before my sons have more to say about how they spend their birthdays, but it warmed my heart just yesterday to hear my son whose birthday is only a couple weeks away say “yeah! I get to stay home with mom on that day” because his birthday falls on a school day. For now, we choose to spend their birthdays together. I hope when they are older and I am old, we can maintain this wonderful tradition. I’ll go wherever they are, though I may need more time off.

What special tradition do you have with your children?

 

Watch DoGS – Dads of Great Students

At the start of the school year, I attended curriculum night for my two elementary age boys. At the general assembly, the principal asked for volunteers to assist the teachers in the classroom. I looked over the volunteer form to find that the only times a parent could support the classroom was between school hours of 9am – 3:30 pm (except Wed which are only til 2pm).

Then, she said “…but don’t worry men, we want you too”. She proceeded to describe a program – the Watch DOGS, which stands for Dads of Great Students – and encourages dads to volunteer for just ONE DAY.
The day is completely pre-programmed. Laid out from start to finish. Tied neatly with a bow.
What?
No, seriously, what?
So moms, regardless of their working status should find a way to come in between 9-3:30 M-F, but dads, just give us one day.
Dads, even if you stay home and want to be more involved with your kids education, you can fulfill the expectations of public school educators with JUST ONE DAY.
I tried signing up for Watch DOGS, but apparently I am not eligible. Do I claim Title IV?

Succeeding almost certainly means I am failing

A talented woman once said, “Whenever you see me somewhere succeeding in one area of my life, that almost certainly means I am failing in another area of my life.”

Who, you ask?

Shondra Rhimes, a successful screenwriter, director, and producer who gave an amazing 2014 Dartmouth commencement speech (her alma mater).

The moment she stated that succeeding necessitated failing, I knew she was speaking the truth. Have you heard the term work life balance? Do you know what it means?

I’m with Ms. Rhimes, it means while one thing is suffering (hopefully temporarily) the other thing flourishes, and hopefully you realize in time to run to the other side of the teeter totter before temporarily means you’ve completely ruined either thing.

Her daily mantra was exactly what I needed on a particularly difficult day, and so I …wake up every single morning and go, “I have three amazing kids and I have created work I am proud of, and I absolutely love my life and I would not trade it for anyone else’s life ever.”